Why Underwater Is Different #1: Lightroom Editing Is Not the Same Below the Surface
Why presets, generic Lightroom tips, and magic-pill fixes often fail underwater, and why a structured workflow creates more natural, consistent results.
If you've watched a Lightroom tutorial for landscape, portrait, wildlife, or travel photos and then tried to use those same techniques for underwater images, you’ve likely encountered the same frustration that many Oceanic Explorers face.
The tutorial makes sense.
The tools seem familiar.
The sliders do what they are supposed to do.
But your underwater photo still does not come together.
The colors may look strange. The water may turn electric blue or muddy green. The subject may look too warm while the background still feels dull. The image may become noisy, crunchy, oversaturated, or flat. Sometimes the edit looks better for a moment, then falls apart as soon as you move to the next adjustment.
That is not because you are bad at Lightroom.
Underwater photography isn't like other types of photography. Editing underwater images is more complex because water alters the image before it even reaches Lightroom.
On land, Lightroom is typically used to adjust lighting, refine tones, enhance colors, and guide the viewer’s focus.
Underwater, it has to do much more: recover colors that water filters out, rebuild contrast that diminishes with distance and haze, separate the subject from the background, reduce particles and backscatter, and make the photo look natural without appearing artificial.
That's why a preset, shortcut, or a single “magic” slider rarely works for underwater photos.
Instead, underwater images require a proper workflow. Not because workflow sounds serious or complex, it's simply because corrections need to be applied in the right order.
For me, that order is simple:
White Balance → Exposure → Presence → Color → Masking → Final Adjustments
That sequence is the backbone of how I teach underwater editing, and it is the reason this new series is called Why Underwater Is Different.
This first post is the foundation.
Before we talk about individual Lightroom tools, AI masking, color recovery, backscatter cleanup, export settings, or presets, we need to understand the bigger idea:
Underwater Lightroom editing is different because the underwater environment creates a different kind of image problem.
And once you understand that, your editing starts to make a lot more sense.
Why Generic Lightroom Advice Often Fails Underwater
Most Lightroom advice is created for land-based photography.
That is not a criticism. Landscape photographers, portrait photographers, wildlife photographers, architectural photographers, and travel photographers all face real editing challenges. But those challenges are not the same as the ones we face underwater.
- A landscape photographer may be working with golden-hour light, clouds, mountains, reflections, and dynamic range.
- A portrait photographer may be correcting skin tone, background separation, catchlights, clothing color, and expression.
- An architectural photographer may be correcting vertical lines, exposure balance, interior lighting, and fine detail.
Those are important problems, but they usually occur in air.
Underwater photography happens through water.
That changes everything.
Water is not just empty space between your camera and your subject. It is an active part of the image. It absorbs color. It scatters light. It reduces contrast. It softens detail. It changes backgrounds. It creates haze. It carries particles. It shifts the color of everything based on depth, distance, water clarity, available light, and artificial light.
This is why a generic Lightroom tutorial can be technically correct and still not be the right answer for an underwater photographer.
- A landscape preset may make a mountain scene richer and warmer. Put that same preset on a reef image, and it may turn the water unnatural, exaggerate the greens, overcook the reds, or make the background look fake.
- A portrait editing method may protect skin tones beautifully on land. Use it underwater, and it may fail because the diver’s face, wetsuit, tank, reef, and water column are all being affected by different types of light.
- A travel photography preset may add pop and contrast. Use it on a low-visibility dive photo, and it may sharpen haze, boost backscatter, and make the image look gritty instead of clean.
That is the problem.
Generic editing assumes the image starts from a relatively normal color and light foundation.
Underwater images often do not.
The Underwater Problem Starts Before Lightroom
When an underwater photo looks dull, blue, green, flat, or hazy, it is easy to think, “I just need the right preset.”
But the real problem began long before the image reached Lightroom.
It began the moment light entered the water.
Warm colors disappear quickly underwater. Reds and oranges fade first. Yellows weaken. Contrast drops as distance increases. Fine detail becomes softer. The farther your subject is from the camera, the more water you are photographing through. If the water is silty or full of suspended particles, the problem worsens.
Strobes and video lights help, but they also introduce their own editing challenges. A strobe may light the subject well while the background remains blue. A close coral head may look warm while the surrounding water looks cool. A diver’s face may need one correction while the water behind the diver needs another. A turtle near the surface may need a completely different approach than a wreck at 90 feet.
That means the underwater image is rarely one simple global problem.
It is often a layered problem.
The subject, background, water, reef, sand, diver, shadows, highlights, and particles may all need different levels of correction.
This is why global presets often fail.
They apply the same recipe to the entire photo, but underwater photos rarely require the same correction throughout.
Why Presets Are Not a Magic Pill
Let me be clear: I am not against presets.
Presets can be useful.
They can save time. They can create consistency. They can help apply a starting look. They can be especially helpful once you understand your own editing style and have already corrected the photo properly.
But presets are not a substitute for judgment.
- A preset does not know how deep you were.
- A preset does not know whether the image was shot in blue water or green water.
- A preset does not know whether you used strobes, video lights, ambient light, or a mix of all three.
- A preset does not know whether the subject is too cool, the background is too saturated, the highlights are too bright, or the shadows are blocked.
- A preset does not know whether the image needs white balance correction, exposure recovery, presence restraint, color separation, masking, cleanup, or export sharpening.
A workflow diagnoses the image.
That is the difference.
Presets work best after you understand what the image needs. If you apply a preset too early, especially to an underwater photo with a weak color or tonal foundation, it may simply exaggerate the problem.
- It may add warmth to a photo that first needed exposure correction.
- It may add contrast to a photo that first needed haze control.
- It may add saturation to a photo that first needed white balance.
- It may add clarity to a photo that first needed backscatter restraint.
- It may create a dramatic look, but not necessarily a believable underwater image.
That is why I teach process before presets.
A preset can support a good workflow.
It cannot replace one.
The Workflow That Makes Underwater Editing More Consistent
The reason I keep coming back to the same Lightroom workflow is simple:
Each step affects the next step.
When you work in the wrong order, you may still improve the image, but you often make editing harder than it needs to be. You may correct one problem while creating another. You may spend time fixing color only to discover later that the exposure was the real issue. You may remove backscatter before deciding the image was not strong enough to finish. You may add masking before the global foundation is stable.
The workflow I teach follows this order:
White Balance → Exposure → Presence → Color → Masking → Final Adjustments
This is not just a list of tools.
It is a decision-making sequence.
Each step answers a different question.
Step 1: White Balance, Build a Believable Color Foundation
Underwater, white balance is not just a creative preference.
It is the foundation for the entire edit.
If white balance is wrong, every color adjustment that follows becomes harder. You may try to fix the coral color with saturation. You may try to warm the subject with Color Mixer adjustments. You may try to correct blue skin with masking. But if the basic color temperature and tint are not believable first, those later corrections may feel like you are fighting the image.
White balance helps answer the first question:
What should neutral look like in this underwater scene?
That does not mean every underwater image should be perfectly neutral. A deep wreck should still feel deep. A blue-water scene should still feel blue. A green-water scene should not be forced into tropical turquoise if that is not what the dive looked like.
The goal is not to remove the feeling of being underwater.
The goal is to remove the color cast that prevents the image from looking believable.
This is why white balance comes first.
It gives every other adjustment a better starting point.
For a deeper dive into this topic, the Back-to-Basics post on white balance is a strong companion piece:
Back-to-Basics Part 5B: White Balance
https://robertherb.blogspot.com/2026/01/back-to-basics-part-5b-white-balance-underwater.html
Step 2: Exposure, Fix the Light Before You Fix the Color
Once white balance is in a believable place, the next question is exposure.
Underwater images often look flat because light has been reduced, scattered, or blocked. But flat does not always mean “needs more color.” Sometimes it means the tonal structure is weak.
- The subject may be too dark.
- The highlights may be too strong.
- The shadows may be blocked.
- The midtones may need lift.
- The background may be brighter than the subject.
- The image may need more tonal balance before it can handle stronger color adjustments.
This is where many underwater photographers get into trouble. They try to fix a dull underwater photo by adding saturation or vibrance too early. That can make the image look colorful, but not necessarily better.
If the exposure foundation is weak, stronger color often makes the image look muddy, noisy, or artificial.
Exposure comes before color because Lightroom needs a stable tonal structure before you ask it to create believable color.
For more on this step, see:
Back-to-Basics Part 5C: Exposure, Highlights, Shadows & Tonal Balance
https://robertherb.blogspot.com/2026/01/back-to-basics-part-5c-exposure-highlights-shadows-underwater.html
Step 3: Presence, Restore Detail Without Overprocessing
Presence tools can be incredibly useful underwater.
Texture, Clarity, and Dehaze can help restore detail, separation, and depth. They can make coral texture more visible, bring back definition in a subject, and cut through some of the flatness caused by water.
But they can also cause problems.
- Too much Texture can make fine detail look rough.
- Too much Clarity can make the image look crunchy.
- Too much Dehaze can darken the water, exaggerate particles, and create an unnatural look.
This is especially important underwater because the camera often records backscatter, haze, and suspended particles along with the subject. If you push Presence too aggressively, you may improve the subject while making the water look worse.
This is why Presence comes after White Balance and Exposure.
You need to know what the image really needs before adding structure and separation.
Presence should restore the image.
It should not punish it.
For a related workflow lesson, see:
Back-to-Basics Part 5D: Presence, Texture, Clarity, and Dehaze
https://robertherb.blogspot.com/2026/01/back-to-basics-part-5d-texture-clarity-dehaze.html
Step 4: Color, Correct, and Refine Without Forcing It
Color is where underwater photographers often want to start.
I understand why.
Color loss is one of the most obvious problems underwater. A scene that looked alive during the dive may appear blue, green, gray, or lifeless on the computer. The natural reaction is to reach for saturation, vibrance, Color Mixer, Point Color, or a preset.
But color works best after white balance, exposure, and presence are already under control.
Why?
Because color is affected by all three.
White balance changes the color foundation.
Exposure changes how bright or dark those colors appear.
Presence changes contrast, separation, and perceived saturation.
If you edit color too early, you may be correcting a problem caused by white balance or exposure.
Underwater color work also needs restraint.
The goal is not to make every reef look neon.
The goal is to recover believable color while preserving the feeling of depth and water.
That means some blue should remain blue. Some shadows should remain cool. Some backgrounds should remain atmospheric. Not every part of the image should be warmed equally.
This is another reason underwater editing is different.
On land, you may often enhance color globally. Underwater, you may need to separate color by subject, background, depth, and light source.
Step 5: Masking, Because Underwater Photos Rarely Need One Global Correction
Masking is one of the most powerful parts of modern Lightroom editing.
For underwater photographers, it is especially important because the subject and background often need different corrections.
A turtle lit by ambient light near the surface may need subtle subject enhancement, while the water needs careful control.
A diver portrait may need warmth and exposure on the face, while the blue background needs to stay natural.
A macro subject may need detail and color separation, while the surrounding area needs to stay soft and quiet.
A wreck may need selective shadow recovery without making the whole scene look flat.
This is why global edits are often not enough.
Underwater light does not affect everything evenly. Strobes fall off with distance. Ambient light changes with depth. The water color shifts across the frame. The subject may be close and warm while the background is distant and cool.
Masking helps you solve those local problems after the global foundation is stable.
That order matters.
If you mask too early, you may spend time making detailed corrections before the overall image is ready. If you mask after the foundation is built, your local adjustments become more precise and less extreme.
For a related lesson, see:
Back-to-Basics Part 5F: Masking and Selective Adjustments
https://robertherb.blogspot.com/2026/02/back-to-basics-5f-lightroom-masking-underwater-photography.html
Step 6: Final Adjustments, Polish After the Image Is Worth Finishing
Final adjustments come last for a reason.
This is where you crop, clean up distractions, reduce remaining backscatter, refine sharpness, check noise, prepare the image for export, and make sure the final photo supports the story you want to tell.
Many underwater photographers want to start with the cleanup.
I understand that too.
Backscatter is annoying. A distracting fin is annoying. A bright particle near the subject is annoying. A poor crop can make the whole image feel weak.
But cleanup should usually come after the main correction work.
Why spend time removing backscatter from an image that may not survive the edit?
Why crop before you know where the subject balance and light will land?
Why sharpen before you know how much noise and texture the edit has created?
Why export before you know whether the image is finished for the platform where it will be viewed?
Final cleanup is important, but it should support the finished image.
It should not replace the workflow that gets the image there.
Where This Fits in the Underwater Lightroom Workflow
This post sits above the entire workflow.
It is not about one slider, one tool, one preset, or one feature. It is about understanding why underwater editing needs a different approach.
The workflow is:
White Balance → Exposure → Presence → Color → Masking → Final Adjustments
Each future post in this series will focus on one piece of that sequence and explain why it matters underwater.
The important point is this:
The workflow is not just what you do. It is the order you do it in.
When the order is right, the edit becomes calmer, cleaner, and more predictable.
When the order is wrong, you may still get a result, but you are more likely to fight the image.
Why This Matters for Oceanic Explorers
If you are an Oceanic Explorer, you probably do not want to spend hours guessing your way through Lightroom.
- You want your underwater photos to look more like what you experienced.
- You want better color without fake color.
- You want detail without crunch.
- You want contrast without harshness.
- You want clean water without plastic-looking subjects.
- You want a repeatable method that works across reef scenes, turtles, divers, wrecks, macro subjects, and blue-water images.
That does not come from memorizing random slider settings.
It comes from understanding the problem and following a sequence that solves it.
That is the heart of this series.
Underwater editing is different because underwater photography is different.
And once you accept that, the goal changes.
You are no longer searching for a magic preset.
You are learning how to read the image.
The Big Takeaway
Lightroom is a powerful tool, but underwater photographers need more than tool knowledge.
They need a workflow built for the way water changes light, color, contrast, and detail.
Generic Lightroom advice can help with the basics, but underwater images require a more specific approach. Presets can help support an edit, but they cannot diagnose the image for you. Magic-pill fixes may look tempting, but they rarely create consistent results across different dives, depths, subjects, and lighting conditions.
That is why I teach a structured underwater workflow:
White Balance → Exposure → Presence → Color → Masking → Final Adjustments
This workflow gives you a way to slow down, make better decisions, and build the image in the right order.
Because underwater editing is not just about making a photo look more colorful.
It is about restoring balance, depth, realism, and intention.
Want to Keep Building This Workflow?
If this way of thinking helps you, I recommend starting with my free guide:
10 Lightroom Fixes Every Underwater Photographer Should Know
https://info.robertherb.com/lm-3
You can also explore the larger editing framework here:
The Complete Guide to Editing Underwater Photos in Lightroom
https://robertherb.blogspot.com/2026/03/editing-underwater-photos-lightroom-guide.html
And if you want to see this workflow taught in a more structured way, you can join the free Masterclass:
Structure Before Drama: The Lightroom Workflow That Fixes Most Underwater Photos
https://info.robertherb.com/lm-4-wait-list
For photographers who want more direct help, feedback, and guided practice, my Cohort Training is designed to help you build consistency across your own underwater images:
Underwater Lightroom Cohort Training
https://info.robertherb.com/cohort-sales-funnel
Coming Next in This Series
In the next post, we will begin with the first and most important step:
Why Underwater Is Different #2: White Balance Must Come First
We will look at why underwater white balance is not just a color adjustment, why it affects every later step in Lightroom, and why starting anywhere else often makes the edit harder than it needs to be.
✍️ Author
Written by Robert Herb
Robert Herb Photography
Empowering underwater photographers to capture and enhance the beauty of our oceans since 1978.
New blogs are published weekly with practical tips to help you transform your underwater photos from dull to WOW.
If you would like to go deeper, visit:
www.RobertHerb.com
or reach out directly at: bob@robertherb.com
I always welcome your feedback and questions.
Sincerely,
Bob Herb
Comments
Post a Comment
Please let me know your comments.